Drawing a Distinction Between Liability as a Surety and Liability as a Surety and Co-Principal Debtor

When you agree to act as a surety, you might also take on the role of a co-principal debtor. Without a clear statement of this additional responsibility, interpreting the terms of the suretyship and the context is necessary to determine if you’re committing as both.

So, what’s the importance of these roles?

  1. Agreeing as both surety and co-principal debtor means you’re on the hook just as much as the original debtor is to the creditor. In simpler terms, your duty to settle the debt is identical to that of the principal debtor’s—both in how much and in what manner. This implies that you and the debtor share the liability fully, without waiting for any conditions to trigger your obligation to pay.
  1. Being a surety and co-principal debtor removes any chance of splitting the debt responsibility with the principal debtor. Essentially, you can’t argue for only paying your ‘share’ of the debt; you’re liable for the whole amount.

This distinction isn’t just legal jargon; it directly affects your financial responsibilities and risks, especially in dealings with financial institutions, business agreements, or situations involving substantial debts. Whether stepping into agreements with creditors, engaging with suppliers for certain goods, or navigating financial difficulties, understanding the depth of your liability as a surety—and potentially as a co-principal debtor—is crucial. This knowledge is particularly relevant if the principal debtor fails to comply, as it shapes the creditor’s actions, which could range from demanding repayment to initiating liquidation processes to recover the debt owing.

Navigating these obligations wisely means taking reasonable steps and seeking advice when entering into such commitments. It’s about knowing not just the immediate implications of standing as a surety but also the full scope of potential financial and legal consequences that accompany the role of co-principal debtor.

Jacqui Smith (LLB)

Legal Advisor

Subscribe now
Read More

More Articles

Road Accident Fund (RAF) Surety Bonds

At Shackleton Risk Management, we can assist you with surety bonds for RAF matters. Surety bonds for RAF matters are provided by Safire Insurance Company Limited (“the Insurer”) and can be lodged by us with the Master on your behalf if needed. Trustees appointed to manage a trust must furnish security to the Master’s satisfaction.…

Read Article > about Road Accident Fund (RAF) Surety Bonds
Do Builders Need Professional Indemnity Insurance in South Africa?

Professional indemnity insurance (PII) serves as a protective measure against claims of professional negligence, errors, or omissions in services rendered. It provides financial coverage for legal costs and compensation payments arising from such claims, ensuring builders are safeguarded against potential liabilities. Legal Requirements and Industry Standards: Unlike certain professions where professional indemnity insurance is mandated…

Read Article > about Do Builders Need Professional Indemnity Insurance in South Africa?
Understanding the Distinction Between Public Liability vs Professional Indemnity Insurance in South Africa

What Is Public Liability Insurance:  Public liability insurance safeguards businesses and professionals against claims for injury or property damage caused to third parties while on their premises or as a result of their operations. It covers legal costs and compensation payments if a third party sues for bodily injury or property damage incurred due to…

Read Article > about Understanding the Distinction Between Public Liability vs Professional Indemnity Insurance in South Africa